RKMBs
Posted By: winged creature Best TV show ever - 2004-04-19 6:43 AM
24
Posted By: rexstardust Re: Best TV show ever - 2004-04-19 6:54 AM
Family guy
or
Alias
Posted By: Darknight613 Re: Best TV show ever - 2004-04-19 7:54 AM
Highlander
Posted By: Mr. Nobody Re: Best TV show ever - 2004-04-19 4:15 PM
Sledge Hammer and Night Court.
Posted By: Grimm Re: Best TV show ever - 2004-04-19 4:19 PM
Quote:

Mr. Nobody said:
Sledge Hammer and Night Court.




dude, you rock.
Posted By: thedoctor Re: Best TV show ever - 2004-04-19 4:25 PM
Quote:

Mr. Nobody said:
Sledge Hammer and Night Court.




Is that you Charlie?
Posted By: the G-man Re: Best TV show ever - 2004-04-19 6:47 PM
Putting aside my own personal preferences and trying to look at it objectively:

First off, how can you name one single show, given all the different genres over the years? Can you really compare the best sitcom to the best drama to the best news program?

Second, how do you define best? By your personal preference? By longevity? By ratings? By critical acclaim?

I think you need to look at programs the way you look at almost any art: a balancing of critical acclaim, commercial appeal, influence on others and longevity.

Using that standard, I'd say that (while it's not a personal favorite of mine) the best sitcom is "I Love Lucy." It pretty much invented the genre (both creatively and technically). It was a critical and commerical success and it is still enjoyed by fans to this day (on Nick at Nite).

Similarly, I'd say the best news program was "60 Minutes," hands down. Every thing else is an imitation and it's still the number one news mag around.

As far as dramas go, that's a little trickier. I'm not sure there was one groundbreaking drama, that one huge hit that wrote the rules the way that Lucy and 60 Minutes did and is still popular today.

I'm tempted to say "Hill St. Blues." It was the first drama to bring a true cinematic sensibility to TV drama, with hand held cameras, overlapping, Mametesque dialogue and better than average production values). It was wildly influential, with its use of multiple story lines and a varied cast of gritty characters (shows as divergent as "the West Wing," "the Sopranos" "24" and "Alias" are owe a debt to HSB and the way that storylines were allowed to continue from week to week, major characters were allowed to change or die and heroes could be cast in shades of grey). And it was a commerical and critical success.

Other thoughts?
Posted By: Jim Jackson Re: Best TV show ever - 2004-04-19 7:43 PM
Comedy: M*A*S*H

Drama: Law And Order

SF: Star Trek (the original's the definitive show, the NEXT GENERATION was better drama)

Variety: Carol Burnett
Posted By: Rob Re: Best TV show ever - 2004-04-19 8:34 PM
i can't really judge anything before my lifetime, so i'll stick with:

simpsons, seinfeld, and cheers

honorable mentions go to ER and the sopranos.
Posted By: PenWing Re: Best TV show ever - 2004-04-19 10:00 PM
Scifi: Babylon 5

Action: Alias

Comedy: Mash

Drama: NYPD Blue, I think.

Overall, Babylon 5.
Posted By: King Snarf Re: Best TV show ever - 2004-04-19 10:43 PM
I'm gonna go with Buffy the Vampire SLayar. This show shouldn't have worked. It was based on Kristy Swanson movie, and it was a mid-season replacement- on the WB!! And yet, it lasted seven seasons, spawned a spin-off which lasted 5 seasons, and has had comics, novels, video games, RPGs, etc. They deftly managed to blend comedy, drama, & horror.
Posted By: Im Not Mister Mxyzptlk Re: Best TV show ever - 2004-04-20 4:51 AM
Seinfeld and Six Feet Under.
Posted By: Irwin Schwab Re: Best TV show ever - 2004-04-20 4:55 AM
Mr Ed it was about a talking horse! HA! a talking horse!
Posted By: Im Not Mister Mxyzptlk Re: Best TV show ever - 2004-04-20 6:00 AM
Tell me more about this... 'Mister Ed'.
Posted By: rexstardust Re: Best TV show ever - 2004-04-20 6:01 AM
I heard he was really a zebra.
Posted By: Im Not Mister Mxyzptlk Re: Best TV show ever - 2004-04-20 6:17 AM
Shouldn't he be called 'Mister Zed' then?
Posted By: Ultimate Jaburg53 Re: Best TV show ever - 2004-04-20 6:23 AM
Babylon 5

Others worth mentioning:

South Park

Newsradio (The Phil Hartman years)

Highlander: The Series

Robotech/Macross

Aquateen Hungerforce

Sealab 2021

Batman The Animated Series
Posted By: Chant Re: Best TV show ever - 2004-04-20 12:48 PM
Best TV shows ever?

I'd go with Farscape, Futurama, and perhaps Red Dwarf...

I'm not much of a Drama guy when it comes to TV shows, it's mostly Sci-Fi and Comedy I watch.

24 was HUGE dissapointment for me.


King of Queens is good too
Posted By: Lothar of The Hill People Re: Best TV show ever - 2004-04-23 4:19 PM
M.A.S.H.
Simpsons
Cheers
Highlander
Star Trek Next Generation
Posted By: Fused Re: Best TV show ever - 2004-04-23 10:48 PM
The Transformers
Posted By: Ace Re: Best TV show ever - 2004-04-25 11:40 PM
Futurama

Family Guy

South Park

Seinfeld

Star Trek

Highlander
© RKMBs