I agree with you, overall. I guess it doesn't bother me too much, as long as it has something of an individualistic or eccentric flair. It doesn't have to be Victorian or Edwardian, necessarily, for me to like it. For example, I loved Eccles' U-Boat Captain outfit, even though it's a variation on something you might see in modern fashion in certain cultures. It all depends on how the actor portrays The Doctor, that defines the vibe the clothes give off. That's why I agree with you, in relation to David Tennant's pretty-boy vibe. Too mainstream feeling for The Doctor, in my opinion.

Also, on a completely unrelated note, I won the K-1 Robot from Baker's pilot episode (titled ever so cleverly) 'ROBOT'.