Well, that's reasssuring. That at least on this occasion it's not a judgement along partisan lines. Unlike all the legal injunctions filed by Obama-appointed judges to prevent Trump's executive orders from being implemented on border security, screening muslim immigrants and so forth.

Regarding the Palin case, 10 years of litigation can't be cheap. If Palin hadn't become wealthy from her celebrity, she might have a very difficult time pursuing justice against the slander that she is somehow responsible for a nut like Loughner shooting Gabby Giffords. Despite the lack of evidence that Loughner ever saw such an ad, and that "targeting" political ads precede Palin by more than 2 decades.