Man, give Eccleston a shot with an open mind. Watch the season as a whole, then decide whether you like him or not. He's pretty damn cool as The Doctor. He's the darkest one, if nothing else.

See, I'm still unsure whether I like Tennant all that much. He's cool and all. But, I just can't get a feel for his goofy "happiness". But, shit, I've only seen three episodes. So, he's still got plenty of room to grow on me. Not to mention, I hate Russel Davies scripts. So, seeing him written by someone else might change my mind...