As a kid I loved Jurgens and Grummett (because his style kinda looked like Jurgens) and hated the other guys (Bog, Guice and Ordway). Bob McLeod was so-so. All of them grew on me eventually, especially the Bogdanove/Janke convo, which art-wise is probably my favorite now. Last year Harley sent me an early Man of Steel issue I didn't have and it made me come with joy (though the picture of her boobs she slipped into the comic probably helped).
Guice's work on Supes was adequate, but it was his work on
Resurrection Man which I really liked.