You said you were glad Penn won even though you haven't seen the film. You expressed an opinion as to whether he deserved the reward without viewing the movie. How is that different than what you questioned BSAMS on?
There was no presumptioun that bsams was wrong for having an opinion on Penn winning. As for me, apparently I'm less emotionally invested in who won best actor than some people. When you threw a very ugly hissy fit when Penn won, I commented that I was glad he won. The comment wasn't based on his performance or if he deserved it or not.
In other words, you questioned BSAMS for basing his opinion of Penn's win on extraneous factors while basing your opinion on extraneous factors too.
