Don't forget Marshall Rogers
Yeah. There's a new hardcover collecting all of Rogers' BATMAN work in a single volume. But I'm not eager to purchase it, because the consensus seems to be it's haphhazardly thrown together.
My favorites by Rogers are his run with Englehart in DETECTIVE 471-476, and the earlier lighter Calculator villain stories in 466-468 (468 being the first Rogers/Austin collaboration).
Also an O'Neil/Rogers story in DETECTIVE 481. And while less than Wein's best, the Clayface story by Wein/Rogers/Giordano in DETECTIVE 478-479.
And the golden age Batman origin story in SECRET ORIGINS 7 (1986) by Roy Thomas/Marshall Rogers.
I thought the 6-issue BATMAN: DARK DETECTIVE follow up about 5 years ago (to DETECTIVE 471-476) was very third-rate and substandard.
All collected in the new hardcover.
But I prefer the material collected in BATMAN: STRANGE APPARITIONS trade.
Regardless, you're right that Marshall Rogers is one of the definitive Batman artists, alongside Neal Adams, Irv Novick, Dick Giordano and Jim Aparo.
For DETECTIVE 443 and 450 alone, I almost want to add Walt Simonson to that list. But those were two beautiful issues, not a sustained and influential run.
Which are different enough from Batman's normal portrayal of the time to almost qualify as WTF material. I understand DC's management didn't care for Simonson's art in 450, much looser than the ACBA award-winning story in 443.
