Quote: My point is: you want your version of Superman to be the only one, ok. But where does that leave the other fans? Why can only one part have their version? This has nothing to do with the Silver Age or the Modern Age: if you were defending the Silver Age the way you're defending the Golden Age I'd say the same things to you.
Ditto. And in fact, I've said much the same thing countless times before.
What I want to see with Superman is integration, a fusion of every incarnation ever done. Be it a mix and match of elements from all the different eras (Birthright, the animated series) or a a wholesale fusion of everything that's ever been done (see Alan Moore's Supreme for an example of how this could be accomplished), I want ALL of Superman's 66-year history to count in some way, for the character to be shaped by ALL of his mythology. I don't want one incarnation to take precedence over all the others. Again, I've said this countless times, and I will no doubt have to say it again until it finally sinks in.
