http://story.news.yahoo.com/news?tmpl=story&cid=597&ncid=763&e=6&u=/nm/20031106/tv_nm/leisure_rules_dc ABC's First Post-Ritter 'Rules' Draws Big Audience
Thu Nov 6, 5:09 PM ET
By Steve Gorman
LOS ANGELES (Reuters) - Tears flowed, the laugh track was turned off and a record number of viewers tuned in as ABC comedy "8 Simple Rules for Dating My Teenage Daughter" returned to prime time with the death of its star, John Ritter (news), written into the story line.
The question now is: Where will the show go from here?
The first episode without Ritter, who died suddenly on Sept. 11 as the sitcom entered its second season, drew nearly 21 million viewers, an all-time high for the series that made the one-hour special the most watched show on TV Tuesday night.
The big tune-in also gave ABC a welcome November "sweeps" boost to two other marquee sitcoms -- third-year series "According to Jim" and sophomore show "Less Than Perfect." Both scored their highest viewership to date, according to Nielsen Media Research.
It remains unclear, however, whether the Walt Disney Co.-owned network can still count on "8 Simple Rules" as a cornerstone of efforts to rebuild its prime-time schedule this season.
With veteran TV performers James Garner (news) and Suzanne Pleshette (news) stepping in to co-star as bickering but supportive grandparents, the fictional Hennessy family will have to keep viewers engaged while walking a fine line between humor and poignancy as they struggle to get on with their lives.
Some critics say that's a tall order for any show to fill, especially in the half-hour format of the traditional sitcom.
Daily Variety critic Brian Lowry predicted in a review on Thursday that having satisfied viewers' immediate curiosity, "one suspects the show will pretty quickly fade."
Alessandra Stanley of the New York Times wrote that the show's family dynamics -- parents coping with the antics of three adolescent kids -- may seem less funny in the aftermath of Ritter's death and that "'8 Simple Rules' may seem like a strange hybrid -- neither a sitcom nor a drama, but some awkward compromise in between."
SOMBER DEPARTURE
Indeed, the show's first post-Ritter episode was a somber departure from its light-hearted former self.
The special opened with Ritter's character, stay-at-home dad Paul Hennessy, having gone out for milk one morning when his wife, Cate, played by Katey Sagal (news), gets a phone call learning that he has collapsed at the grocery store.
As the emotional story unfolds, tears are shed, hugs are exchanged and bittersweet humor is proffered while family members deal with their father's death. The episode was taped without a laugh track.
In strictly commercial terms, the show was a huge success, easily surpassing the robust ratings of the last three Ritter episodes, which aired after his death at the start of the fall season.
The loss of a parent is rare territory for prime-time sitcoms, although widowhood has been an underlying premise for a number of well-known examples of the genre, among them "The Andy Griffith (news) Show," "My Three Sons," "The Partridge Family" and "The Courtship of Eddie's Father."
In the 1960s series "Family Affair," three orphans move in their wealthy bachelor uncle and his butler.
But "8 Simple Rules" must transform itself mid-stride from a sitcom about the give and take between a harried father and his precocious teenage daughters to a series focused on a widowed mother and her family trying to put their lives back together.
Can the series make the transition? As Sagal told TV Guide in a recent interview: ""There's no road map. ... It's really flying without a net. So much about life is flying without a net."