Quote:

ManofTheAtom said:
If I was told "remake Superman" I would write something that wouldn't be MoS and wouldn't be BR.



I'm sorry, but I don't believe you. That would be the right thing to do, but I doubt you'd do it. I think you would simply use the chance to ignore Birthright and go back to where the MoS continuity was left in 1999.

Quote:

If I was told "fix Superman" then I'd address the BR problem and take Superman back to his Post Crisis MoS roots.



Oh. Well, there you go. That's what I was saying. Like it or not, MoS is in the past. Going back to it is as bad as going back to the 60's. In fact, worse than going back to the 60's, since there hasn't been a "breathing period" to properly separate it from what goes on today. Bringing back the 60's, as lame as it may be, at least would give us a new different look on an era.

Quote:

Remember, MoS is the origin of consequoence, it's the one that came after Crisis.



I'm sorry, but that only means something if you're a continuity obsessed fan. Since I'm not one, that means nothing to me. It could have come after Invasion! for all I care.

Quote:

I have no loyalty to the credit box.

If BR had been the one that came after Crisis and it was being replaced by MoS in the same half assed way as it's happening now, it would deserve the same kind of disdain.



Then why did you say that other time that if there was a Crisis like event to support Birthright you'd be up for it?