My favourite Christmas stories are the ones from when I was a kid:

That issue of DC COMICS PRESENTS where Superman teams up with Santa Claus against the Toyman (long before he became a goth child-killer... Toyman, not Santa Claus, of course). I think it was #67.

Also, the FUNNY STUFF STOCKING STUFFER from 1984/85 was fun. It starred a lot of DC's golden age funny animal characters updated slightly for the '80s.

There were also a few issues of THE BEST OF DC -- which was a digest-sized series of mostly reprints -- that reprinted some Christmas stories. Two of my favourites were the ones reprinting RUDOLPH, THE RED-NOSED REINDEER by Shelly Mayer (issue #4) and the SUPER JRS. HOLIDAY SPECIAL from issue #58 (1984) that was an all-new 65 page adventure and was very entertaining to my 10-year-old self.



(I'll probably edit in some covers for those later on.)