Complaints:
Every time I visit the forums anew, I have to log in. This might be a problem with my security/cookie settings, though. I'll look into it.
I dislike the new graemlins. And please be sure the new graemlins with urls the same as the ones we used to use. (Though I'm sure you knew that a long time ago, I still had to say it.) So many placeholders where faces used to be.
This short-ass post window is crap! Story posts and other long-winded garble (such as this) is a pain.
Don't like the Post Icons either. I've always found them dumb and much more suitable for the DCMB-ish crowd.
I hate the fact that "Edited by..." is displayed at the bottom of posts. Again, story posts and other long-winded garble.
That Home link at the top that takes me to your homepage is annoying, Rob. Your site's mainpage is probably getting more hits now, but put it at the bottom, or somethin'.
Why do I feel like the old boards were... rounder? The old design seemed to have more curves. Or maybe my medication finally kicked it...
If I highlight something and press one of the UBB Code buttons, why doesn't it just make what I highlighted bold, italicized, or whatever. It has to take me to another screen so I can re-type it in. This perturbs me.
That last one was nitpicking. I've always hated the space after inserted UBB Code, though.
Banners. Forums need their banners back.
Likes:
I like the option of going to My Page first. Lets me see my PMs and I can glance quickly at my favorite threads list to see if anyone's posted to 'em. That's cool.
COLORS
The automatic post preview is cool. I was annoyed by it until I realized I could turn it off permanently in my page.
My options page is generally better. More options are a good thing.
Pictures in sigs are the shiznit.
The overall transition was very smooth, especially for the holiday season. Good job, Rob.
