Quote:

Im Not Mister Mxypltk said:
What are you talking about? People are bitching that he's too crazy and that the narrative is too fucked up.




Because they think he's not crazy in the first place. It never occurs to anyone that maybe--Just maybe he is crazy.

Quote:

When did Morrison ever touch the subject? Not on JLA. I'd be interested in reading that.




You didn't read Arkham Asylum?

Quote:

No, I'm saying the in-continuity one doesn't make sense: his actions (insane) aren't consequent with his behaviour (sane). This one is consequent in every way: crazy actions equal a fucked up psyche (hence the narrative). The regular Bat-Man runs over some cop and keeps a straight face and the narrative justifies his actions; this one is laughing like a maniac the whole time.




I'm prolly nit-picking here, but I don't know if that's fair. I mean, there's many different types of disorders. Some are blatant (All-Star Batman), others are more subtle (continuity Batman).