as for the movies:
1-sucked. it was too god damned long and boring and had too many scenes that were just "marvelling" at the awe of the 1979 graphics. also the uniforms were pastels and too tight.
2-great the first time, but only good on re-watching. i like that they admitted the cast was old and they stopped trying to make shatner sexy which let everyone put actual acting into their character.
3-meh. its really 2.5 and not its own film.
4-great. the most financially successful trek film for a reason: the crew on modern day earth is funny and non-trek fans can enjoy it. its the only star trek that people who hate star trek can watch.
5-worst of the TOS movies. bad acting, meandering plot, just a complete piece of shit.
6-my personal favorite of the TOS films. its just a good story that serves as a real finale to Kirk's era and also deals with the "old soldier" metaphor nicely and parallels the fall of the USSR.
7-never felt this was a film, more a last episode for TNG with torch-passing bits. overall a good film with nice A and B plots. the Enterprise crashing was cool and really more of a surprise than Kirk dying.
8-the best trek movie. its creepy and funny and just plain cool. its a trek film you can use to justify liking star trek.
9-terrible piece of shit. i was really let down. i wasn't sure if this was supposed to be a comedy or a serious morality drama. either way it failed on both marks.
10-long, boring, pointless, and basically ripped off elements of prior trek films and cut down a lot of really nice character scenes (you can find them on youtube, including an extended ending that was much better than the theatrical one).

Bow ties are coool.