Quote:

Ultimate Jaburg53 said:
Well if they were four of the final five then why did they torture Tigh and pluck out his eye?



They didn't know he was a cylon. If they didn't know he was a cylon, why wouldn't they torture their enemy?

Quote:

Ultimate Jaburg53 said:
Also it seems rather coincidental that two of them just happened to be the number two people to the Admiral and the President.



That is a little much.

Quote:

Ultimate Jaburg53 said:
Does this mean that the Cylon intentionally let the Galactica and it's fleet survive the initial attack on the twelve colonies?



No, it means the cylons don't know who the final five are. Besides, there are probably copies of them on a secret ship.